The St Andrews Castle Course has divided opinion since its inception and it is easy to see why. Almost all of the greens seem to have not one, but several elephants buried beneath them and the random mounds in the fairways, which thankfully don't have rough on them anymore, accurately recreates the unfairness of traditional links courses. Despite this we really liked the Castle course. Yes the greens are mad and you dont wan't to play the Castle Course with a card in your hand, but we enjoyed the challenge they provided. The slopes make the effective areas around the flags very small and better players will appreciate the skill this requires to get it close and the course management decisions that need to be made.

Most of the trouble around the greens is long so play short and putt up those slopes and you will find it is manageable. Greens aside this is a marvellous layout. Unlike the overrated Kingsbarns, there are no weak holes here and the bunkering looks great and they are deep enough to cost you a shot, even on the fairway. The views on every hole are magnificent as you are that much closer to the town and the 2 stretches of holes by the coast from 6 to 9 and 16 to 18 offer dramatic views and even more dramatic shots over the cliffs. The clubhouse is beautifully laid out too, although the 'broom cupboard' showers could do with a rethink. The only other issue is the price. Unless you are a mmeber at a Scottish Golf Club, the green fee will be only a few pounds less than the Old Course, which is way too much. Howevere if you can afford it, then the Castle Course is well worth playing.